South Jersey’s Beloved Fool Moon Theatre

South Jersey’s Beloved Fool Moon Theatre Seeks Its Next Act

South Jersey’s beloved Fool Moon Theatre has been a cultural cornerstone since its founding in 2005. Described as a “wandering trade” by Shakespeare, the theater has truly lived up to the phrase. From its initial home at United Trinity Methodist Church in Ventnor, the nonprofit has traveled through several venues, including Margate Community Church, Dante Hall in Atlantic City, and two locations in Somers Point. After enjoying a three-year residency at Margate Community Church, the company now finds itself, once again, searching for a home.

Last September, Fool Moon’s production of The Miracle Worker was met with acclaim, marking the end of its tenure at Margate. Despite this challenge, the theater continues to draw a loyal audience and maintain its reputation for delivering high-quality productions.


Building a Legacy Despite Challenges

Through years of change, Fool Moon Theatre has remained a cherished institution, thanks to its passionate team of performers and its variety of shows. From musicals like A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum to deeply moving dramas like Proof and Love Letters, the theater offers something for everyone. Its production list even includes hidden gems like A Bad Year for Tomatoes, reflecting its commitment to diversity and artistic exploration.

Co-founder and executive director Paul Herron explains, “We’ve developed great casts and chosen shows that bring people together. It’s been a journey, but we’ve kept building all the way.”

Performers span all age groups, from children to seniors, creating an inclusive and supportive environment. Local resident Becky Maegerle, whose daughter starred in Forum, highlights how Fool Moon has been instrumental in fostering confidence and creativity in its participants. “It’s heartbreaking to hear they’re currently without a home,” she shares, emphasizing the theater’s importance to personal growth and community connections.


A Small Theater Making a Big Impact

Despite its size, Fool Moon Theatre has made an impressive mark. The company has received accolades such as Bronze Stars in the Press of Atlantic City’s “Best of the Press” awards and multiple nominations for BroadwayWorld New Jersey Awards.

Board member Kate Read notes, “We’re small compared to bigger theaters like the Levoy or Gateway, but what Fool Moon achieves in small spaces is nothing short of magical.” Indeed, the theater’s ability to transform modest venues into immersive theatrical experiences has set it apart.

In addition to entertaining audiences, Fool Moon has demonstrated its commitment to giving back. By partnering with nonprofits like Gilda’s Club and the South Jersey Food Bank, the theater has used its platform to raise funds for vital causes. These collaborations highlight Fool Moon’s role as more than just a creative outlet—it’s a unifying force within the community.


The Financial Struggles of Local Theater

Running a theater company comes with its share of financial hurdles, particularly in an area where real estate costs are high and seasonal residency affects donor contributions. Fool Moon is currently searching for a venue that can host auditions, rehearsals, and performances while seating at least 100 people.

Herron humorously notes, “Our audience has been kind enough to endure hard chairs for years. They’re dedicated, and we truly appreciate that.”

Fool Moon’s aim is to return with at least two productions in 2025, ideally within the Ventnor-Margate-Atlantic City-Somers Point area, where its core audience resides. The search is on for a partner willing to provide space and share in the mission of fostering arts in the community.


Hope for the Future

For fans like Maegerle, the thought of Fool Moon’s absence is devastating. “Losing such a treasured experience would be a great loss, not just to our family but to the entire community,” she says.

Artistic director Marlene May of South Jersey Players also roots for Fool Moon’s resurgence, emphasizing its unique ability to “transport audiences through theater.” She views the theater not as a competitor but as part of a close-knit arts community.

As Fool Moon Theatre looks ahead, its leaders remain optimistic. “We’re hoping for a miracle,” Herron says. With its history of resilience and the unwavering support of its community, Fool Moon is determined to find its next stage.


Get Involved

Organizations interested in supporting Fool Moon Theatre can reach out to Paul Herron at 609-457-0903 or via email at [email protected]. For more information, visit FoolMoonTheatre.org.

Disclaimer – Our team has carefully fact-checked this article to make sure it’s accurate and free from any misinformation. We’re dedicated to keeping our content honest and reliable for our readers.

Related Posts